Wednesday, August 17, 2011

phew!! jan lokpal..

The opinions are strong and emotions are high..
The society(FB or otherwise) has been mainly divided into two groups - people who have been following the ANNA movement, know whats at stake and hence have strong opinion for or against ANNA. Secondly the people who caught the news when it reached prime time, heard it on all the news channels in one hour and 'share'd an opinion with the journalist.

These people whom I have classified as the 'second' group  are the real soul of India, who work from dawn till evening, people who actually have to fight with everyday issues which our corrupt and inefficient system throws at us. These are the people, who in spite of all the 'business losses', do make it a point to cast their vote, these are the people who think and hope that their franchise will actually make a difference. So these are the people take out whatever time hey can for the nation, society. And for all these reasons these are the people who have the actual right to form an opinion about issues such as this. Unlike the less ignorant ones who, probably from their birth time, knew that nothing is going to change so they do not vote, or since the elections always take place when they have an important meeting or trip.

But unfortunately the people, whom I classify as the real soul of India, are always exploited the most by the powers that may be - politicians or media, babas or celebrities. So basics of this Anna movement is the same - get this group behind you. To their credit - the Anna team has been very very transparent in their approach . They have published their demands in all the possible forms and on all possible platforms. They have tried to explain it to the people what their demands mean and what 'they think' is going to change if their demands are met.  Anna ji has a very clean character as even congress' most efficient sniffers could not find any thing against him or his close aides. Such person does deserve all the support he needs to put forward his idea and I think he must be answered honestly by the people which we have elected.

But the question is how many of the people who are at the streets actually understand that tabling a draft of a bill is no victory by any means, how many of the people think - how adding another bureaucratic position in our already complex bureaucratic system is going to help the common man? Do all of these people even know or have thought about how these lokpals are going to be appointed or transferred or 'enquired' or suspended. Are all these people ready for an IAS officer sitting on top of all our political system - given that we have more than 50% reservation in government appointment/promotion system.

First things first - let me present an hypothetical situation. Tomorrow, lets assume that, the govt agrees to the demands of the team Anna and tables their draft of the lokpal bill in the parliament. Now congress 'high command' issues a public statement that all its MPs have a democratic right to decide if they want to vote for or against the bill - do we think even a single congress MP is going to vote in favor of the bill. BJP, as double standard as they  are, are they going to vote in favour?? they will always want this issue to hang around, passing it makes life so easier for congress, so why will BJP vote in its favor?  So the chances of the bill becoming a law are very very bleak. Do these people, on the streets, even know that they might have come out again when the 'lower house' rejects the bill(and that could be 'release time' for many!! Sorry for this bad joke.. ).

Now lets assume that the team Anna, given that they have been spot on with their timing and campaigning, are able to pull out three  or four 'revolutions' and get to pass all these hurdles. We have a new Lokpal anointed( by Congress or by reservation!!). He enjoys absolute power to question anybody, including the PM, military brass??, NSA, Foreign Sec so and so forth... What happens if such a person is corrupt or biased or politically/socially inclined. Who measures the performance for him - in other words who has the power to 'transfer' him. A PM(selected by SG), a president (selected by SG), parliament('majority led' by SG, 'opposition led' by 'SS', session led by Miera LOL Kumar), or a supreme court bench.
The makers of our constitution had invested absolute powers in the hands of elected representatives of the people. Hence by the spirit of our constitution - the 'aam aadmi' has the indirect absolute power. We, over the period of time, have been casting our votes for money, a bottle of liquor, religion, cast. Now, all of sudden, some body tells us that a revolution is just a click away and we, frustrated over our own failures,   are, quiet understandably,  going to give in and believe. It s easy, free and hence makes sense.

Now another question which, I am sure, will further divide all those on the street - Will we support 50% reservation for the post of Lokpal, 33% women reservation as well?? I know this question can be answered later but do we think the lokpal, assuming that he got selected coz he belonged to a certain caste or certain tribe, will not be biased. Do we think a such a person, who does not get selected because of his abilities but for other reasons,  will not be politically or economically (in other words - bribed, corrupt) biased.  We all have heard horror stories of IAS/IPS officers preparing the choona/pan masala for our MPs and MLAs - so do we know the answer if the LOKPAL will be the product of this bureaucratic-political system or not.

On a second(or sober) thought - if I read what all I am saying can simply be described as a knee jerk reaction of a very pessimist man. But then to my defence - I will never describe myself as a pessimist of any degree and secondly I am more worried about the people who think the 'revolution' is just a bill, mouse-click or march away..
But as I had written in my last post one more option is not going to hurt 1.2 billion(ok 50% of 1.2 billion) voters.. and Anna's team is more than a good political option this revolution is going to give us.


3 comments:

  1. Beautifully done but I can hear a pessimist but then I cant blame you, its our corrupt rituals which makes a mango indian think like that!

    Talking about what if the person who is elected for the Lokpal turns corrupted?... is a question/fear for the future similar to our other all day every day 'what ifs' - what if the plane crashes, what if there is a bomb blast, what if there is an accident and so on and so forth however the best bit is despite of all these 'what ifs' we still travel by plane, walk/travel on the same road for mainly 2 reasons 1. you have no choice 2. you cant stop living! Therefore, I personally believe actions were long awaited and are performed brilliantly by the so called Team Anna. People want things to change and after a long time atleast with all of Anna's efforts, few are convinced that the change is possible. so now lets be optimistic n hope that this turns out to be a boon and all the efforts put in are worth it!

    I am pasting a link below which explains in the simplest of the words 'what is Lokpal bill'

    https://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=1820332153005&comments

    God night!

    ReplyDelete
  2. very well said, but I agree more with the comment by this lady. Pessimism - but yes difficult to associate with you.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good to see something new from u after a long time. I am not into the details of the jan lokpal bill but i do know that majority of people out there on the street are partially for the cause but majorly because they want to click pics, upload on FB and share it with people next day in office/college/friends circle... that see! I was there and i was fighting for the cause. I guess even if i would go there i would be doing the same. But then, the only thing which i found very amazing is that at least there is no harm to public property. and i hope it continues like this!

    ReplyDelete