Tuesday, August 6, 2019

what about them?

Wow! it has been seven years since I wrote anything! 

If I did not know myself any better, I would say that the old age has calmed me down. But the truth is that I have, just, not felt motivated enough to write anything. Post Arvind Kejriwal/IAC era everybody has become an expert and polarisation is so absolute that it has become impossible to have a constructive discussion. 

The only reason, I am trying to jot down my thoughts today, is that I have been asked, time and again, by a friend to put down my strong views on different topics, we discuss in our chats. 

And, removal of special status afforded to J&K seemed as good a topic as any. 

I must confess I am still struggling to get my thoughts together on this. My first reaction was that it was very brave step and only Modi could have done it. 

But that was exact reaction on demonetisation - A very bold move, something which was long overdue!

But what was wrong with demonetisation, or air-strikes on PoK or GST - they were all undercooked policies, hasty decisions followed by loud and vulgar publicity. 

Congress has created some wonderful policies over the years but what Congress could never achieve was - any success in implementing them. Has BJP achieved any success with demonetisation, GST, Smart villages, Swach Bharat or  even MNREGA or Adhar Card deployment? Bhagats will tell you their side of the story but my argument is that we have not seen a positive impact of any of these on the ground.

Every policy is still a promise,  still a dream. 

One major difference I have seen this time around is that BJP leaders are not patting their own back on the current "achievement" but, still, there is no shortage of vulgar jokes on the social media. 
And that is my concern in all this. 

From the political standpoint it makes sense to bifurcate J&K. This will give government of India better control and, perhaps, better access to different parts of the region. But I would have liked to see Jammu distanced from the troubled land. Jammu has mostly been a peaceful city and people there identify themselves as Indians. I have always thought that people of Jammu have been suffering unnecessarily all these years. It would have made more sense to cut Jammu  out, long ago.  While Congress never had enough guts to bifurcate the state, it seems it suits BJP to keep Jammu and Kashmir together, political demographics and all!

It also makes sense to include J&K into the mainland India. Once kashmiri youth starts working in Delhis, Bangalurus and Hydrabads of the country, they will find out what India has to offer - a truly secular nation which is just polarised by the politicians and their social media cells.( and, of course, criticised by Sonia Deols).

But, I am worried how this is celebrated as a victory by huge middle class of the country, which, actually, does not have any knowledge of the history of the state. I can bet many of those who sent me those "jokes" on social media do not even know why was article 370 added to the constitution. They  praise Patel and swear on Nehru-Gandhi family without knowing what the Kashmir issue is, without knowing anything about circumstances and conditions under which India was allowed to send its armed forces into Kashmir in 1947. 


As I have advocated many a times in the past, since Kashmiri youth does not want to be a part of India, they should be given their place and peace.
Personally, I know some kashmiri pundits who were threatened and kicked out of their homes and I know that that generation wanted to go back. But if you ask the next generation who has been educated in mainland India, I do not think they care. They consider themselves lucky to have escaped a war zone. 


To my suggestions on "giving Kashmir to Kashmiris", I have heard counter arguments like
   - This is not good for the security of the country as it gives both China and Pakistan a better access to mainland India.
    - This will set a bad precedent and then we will have to give away Assam, Gorkhaland and Punjab.
    - This is what Pakistan wants, and India cannot be seen defeated by a country whose only contribution to humanity is the terrorist camps(and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan!!). 

And while I do not have a logical answer to all these valid points - my romanticised argument is that where are the interests of the kashmiri youth in all these? This issue has already destroyed 3-4 generations of Kashmiris and the world is no more wise than it was in 1947. Pakistan is still exporting terrorists to every corner of the world and will continue to do that. UK, China, US(even toe-nail sized countries of Europe) will like to continue to sell arms and ammunitions to this part of the world and hence will want this to be a burning issue for another 80 years. 

Someone has to think about the people of kashmir. 

Saturday, February 1, 2014

I do not remember when i wrote this..

Let me first wake up those who think what has happened today has never happened before. I remember Barkh Dutt uttering the exact words on National TV after the public outrage on Mumbai attacks, as many as, four years ago. A simple law and order problem was made to look like an international terrorism racket in an attempt which was unsuccessful in uniting the nation again these sponsors of terrorism but was successful in making the public belive that IT IS NOT A LAW AND ORDER problem. Similarly now the same government has made us believe that it was SOCIAL PROBLEM and not a law and order issue. A problem with the psyche of the men in this country, a problem with the kind of stuff which is shown in movies, a problem with media too active, a problem with opposition doing politics but the government has not failed to provide its citizens their right to live.
Only difference between 2012 and 2008 - the role of media. Media, specially the media which caters to the "facebook" part of the society was very bold and forth coming in bashing the government during Mumbai attacks and because of that, at least Shivraj Patil had to go. But as I had written a few months ago government seemed to have learned a lot from mumbai attacks. Over the period of few months after its re-election government tightned its fist around media, and this time around journos were blatantly justifying the lathi charge on the "rougue elements in the protestors" untill they were on the threshold of loosing any faith left in them.
One of the first steps the world governments have been taking to get rid of racism is by making a law against it and then implementing it. And racism is a social problem but crime against a section of society is a criminal problem. A problem with imeplementation of law and order.

Of many sad incidents which "became" quiet sensational during last fifteen days or so, let us try to find out who all suffered - the poor lady herself, her family, protesters, 5 DD employees, some constable level delhi traffic police personal, unfit and untrained (and perhaps unpaid for last six months) police  constable... any once else.. yes the families of the accused. 

Rapist will suffer, we all know, as the powerful people who made them believe that they can commit this crime and get away have now distanced themselves from them. Media has reached the native village of one of the accused but could reach the owner of the bus, that guy has twenty nine route permits in Delhi and he is a resident of Noida but no body wants us to wonder if any of his licenses have been cancelled as he was running a chattered bus without permission. And is it illegal to declare the name of his transport company on National TV??

Only rich sufferer on the tragedy, one who made me write this, is the rapper Honey Singh. Till about day before yesterday I did not have any speciall affection for the man but today I firmly believe that he has been unfairly treated. Yes his songs were( and repeat WERE) offensive and quiet outrageous but








Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Unsafe roads is NOT the actual problem


My exposure to India news is limited to Facebook and Twitter, these days, as they are currently the only sources of genuine, unbiased information. From the kind of reaction I have seen on Facebook, the title of the post is going to get some eyebrows raised but that is not the intent behind choosing this title. In fact first thing, which came to my mind after reading different reactions about the Delhi rape case was that “unsafe roads at night” is NOT THE CORRECT DEFINATION OF THE PROBLEM.

Just like in case of 26/11 attacks - Kasab or ISI or Pakistan government were NOT THE ACTUAL PROBLEM.

Here is the actual problem -

A chatered bus can freely move on delhi roads for hours, without being questioned. The bus had the permit to ferry around school children only but still it went roaming around in the city unnoticed and unchecked. Anybody who has any experience of working for a transport company in India will tell you that such a pick-up drop service could not have been operating without consent of all the competing transporters on that route and without the consent of traffic police personals.

The licensed driver can hand over a public transport vehicle to his brother. That is another problem which everyone - transporters, their employees, police personal, media, everyone wants us to ignore. For their own vested interests as most of the transport companies are run by the rich and the powerful.

Ever wondered - the first thing the driver, of a bus or a truck, does, when he meets an accident, is - flee away. We have heard that story so many times. Here is what actually happens - the transport companies measuredly hand over their vehicles to drivers which do not have valid licenses. As such drivers, with a valid license to drive a public transport vehicle, are in short supply everywhere. So the “driver” keeps on plying on pan India roads - bribing the corrupt traffic police personal every time he is asked for a license. On a fateful day when he meets some accident or kills a few people on the road, he follows the guideline of his employer to run away as soon as possible. The employer then asks a valid license holder to "surrender". Because if you kill a few people on road and you have a valid license - you are booked under negligent driving. But if you do not have a valid license you can be booked under murder or homicide. I can assure you that more than half of the blue line buses in the capital are run by unlicensed drivers.

A privately owned car in delhi cannot have tinted glasses but a public transport vehicle can go unnoticed for years without being questioned. Okay my knowledge on laws concerning the tinted glasses is limited to fact that I know that a car belonging to a law abiding citizen of India cannot have tinted glasses. Even if you have a "certified tint" you cannot escape the efficient traffic police department of Delhi Police or even Amritsar police for that matter. But I shudder to think that these is this loop hole in our law which allows a public transport vehicle, ferrying young school children, operated by a private organisation to operate with tinted or curtained windows.

A man who gets looted by a permit holder public transport vehicle does not go to police station to file an FIR. I mean if I was in place of that man who escaped by losing just eight thousand bucks - I would have never gone to a police station in Delhi. I have been to a Delhi police station twice in my life and both the time nobody even hear me out properly, leave alone any attempt at recording the crime or acting upon the claim. One of these times I was, actually, threatened by eunuch that - "I will come back again tomorrow when your newly married wife will be alone at home".

Media wants us to believe that a tough law will solve the problem of rape. . There are multiple angles to this story. Media keeps talking about the "capital punishment for rape" as they know that Sex, in any form, sells. People like to talk about such issues so let the tapes rolling.

For those who, actually, think a tough law will help solve the problem - recent misuse of IT law should serve as an eye opener. Every law in India will only be used against a common law abiding citizen in India.

Shiela Dixit or Sonia Gandhi are too aloof from this society understand root causes of our societal issues, and their babus would not tell them the truth. But I know what I am going to do on this issue – I am going to ask all these questions to any of my relatives who are in police/civil administration services and ask them if they think it is their fault

 

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Cheering the points table..


The olympics are over and every country who participated - is analysing its performance. For me it was a splendid show by Indian sports person - given the kind of training facilities these players get in India.
But just yesterday I came across an article in THE HINDU. The author blames the India obsession with cricket as the primary, if not the only, reason for poor state of other sports in India. He claims that the nation will forget these heroes as soon the Indian cricket team will win a tournament in the conditions tailored to their style.
(While talking about forgotten heroes, quiet ironically, he takes the name of Jeev Milkha Singh, but not his father!!)
I have heard similar arguments in the past - coming from wanna be Me Different or people who do not understand the sports in general and Cricket in particular. But this coming from a (wanna be??) sports journalist of one of the most respected news paper of the country was - strange, to say the least. Although I do not know anything about the author, nor have I tried to search his credentials before writing this - so as to give an honest opinion about what I have read and what I feel like bashing. My first impression about the article was that this is an attempt to present people with what they want to read or hear, when they want to hear it. But then one does not expect this from a newspaper like THE HINDU.
Few of the arguments given by the author were, simply put, ridiculous. Take for instance -
 "Let’s look forward to another wild parade through the streets of Mumbai with the boys peacocking from an open-top bus..."
another one -
"Instead, we spend sleepless nights over whether Chennai Super Kings would make it to the final of the IPL or....; or whether Yuvraj Singh is dating the latest Miss India or some other starlet whose only claim to fame is that she was seen with a cricketing superstar on a night out."

It is very clear that the author does not understand sports or psyche of a sports fan. For a normal cricket lover it makes no difference whom is Yuvraj Singh dating. I mean more than half of cricket lovers will not know the name Sachin's or SauravG's wives. If media had not made news out of what Dhoni's wife wears to a party  - a cricket fan would not care.
Secondly cricket is the religion in India ONLY because it is the only sport in which we have been challanging the world for a few decades, only game which has given us icons like SunilG, SachinT, RahulD, KapilD.. so and so forth. Hockey was already dead by the time I took birth but the stardom of DhyanC speaks volumes about how popular it must have been when we were a power in hockey. Till the time PTUsha was playing I know people of India waited for Asian Games. I have seen people taking to tennis when PaesBhupathy used to beat every Tom dick and harry of mens double tennis.
So point I am trying to make is that you cannot make 120Billion people follow a sport trying to shake the conscious of a particular(english reading) class of the society. I remember in Doordarshan days there used to be programs on preparations of athletes, their introduction to the masses just before any major event. But..
The people of India have not failed any sport - the people who wield power in India have failed everyone and in every field. What has any media house done to fight for better training facilities for these athletes - absolutly nothing. Media houses who talk about the unabashed power of BCCI - were even bigger culprits in the blatant murder of ICL.
I am not passing the buck - as a common man - I love cricket and I do not disrespect any game. I am sure every common man who had access has tried to watch as many Indian events in olympics as possible. Even if he did not understand the game - he has cheered the points table, with all his might.
Yes, with so much of our tax going down the drain we have every right to feel bad when we are confronted with the truth that an olympics qualifier could not get minimal facilities where as the ex president has a private GYM, a public office has spent 35lac INRs on toilets.
So lets get this straight Mr WannabeAsportsJournalist - Since a follower of a religion does not disrespect other religion - we have nothing against other sports. Yes somebody,powerful, will have to stick their head and show some will to improve the state of sport administration in India. Politicians are not doing it, media has not shown any will to show any fight, Indian middle class, having shown so much patience over the years, will take it in its hands. Let us just get the JNLP rolling first.



Friday, August 3, 2012

A mistake repeated..

When Mahtama Gandhi, referred to as MKG from here on, forced the political leadership of the country to spare a huge sum of 650 million INRs for the newly formed Pakistan - he did not know it was going to be talked about as yet another mistake of his life. Within a few months everybody knew the money given, so that our "brothers" could start a dignified life, was being used to buy arms against us.
This was not the first political blunder MKG had committed - publicly accepting that he hated Bhagat Singh and his modus-operandi was perhaps the first, and for a punjabi a bigger one!! A person who single handedly brought about the freedom struggle in South Africa, who fought so many battles for equal rights for everybody in the society, coined the term- harijans, fought for the welfare of women in India - had so many haters. This only proves he did not know how to conduct his life publicly. Politics is for people like Nehru - who can tweak the history books such that hist next seven generations rule the country. Politics is not for people who believe in a single idea - you just cannot call off a movement(Civil Disobedience) just because your followers are doing something you are so against.(violence, killing people). In politics you understand the pulse of the masses- not do what you think is right.

Indian middle class today is not interested in a slow process of democratic reforms - democracy has been more of a bane for the current generation at least. They want a magical wand to cleans the "system", some very powerful force which will ONLY punish the bad guys. Janlokpal had taken to their imagination - all of a sudden the middle class man started feeling some sense of hope, hence responsibility and obligation to do something. And in Anna they had found a man of strong character - someone who believed in his ideas as strongly as the MKG. Again a man who had started off his journey on social reforms and had hence build up a strong following. Again a man who is too honest to be politician. He had taken up the war against every one - Govt, oppositions, babus, media every one. Anybody who has worked even a small private corporation could tell you that these guys were amateurs, to say the least. Congress, who had ruled this country for last sixty years manipulated and negotiated with them like a skilled HR personal. So not even a single comment from the prime minister in their ten days of hunger strike and a threat from the police chief to force feed them were enough for the team Anna  to start contemplating other options.

India, with the advent of MKG in the political scene paid with dire consequences - a constitution written in English being one of them. I just hope this Gandhian proved out to be a better 'political alternative' than the first one. I hope that they do not get swallowed by the political whales of this country. I hope they do not face an embarrassing defeat in their first campaign itself. I hope team Anna, at least, brings about some hope of a change, if not the change itself in the next general elections.

And atlast I hope BJP promises them a janlokpal and they join forces against the congress - we cannot afford Rahul Gandhi at the helm of affairs.





Wednesday, May 9, 2012

A burden of being the rulers


If you happened you lay your hand on any of the english newspapers today, and I repeat ANY, you must have read at least one word "ASIAN". To be more precise, things like – “ASIAN SEX RACKET” or "Asian sex gang”.

The news - few brown skinned men, with muslim names, found running a prostitution racket.
The outcry – All the media houses labelled these men as ASIANS, but none of them tried to justify the label. Nobody told us who these men were, how many years have they been living here, where were these men born, educated(if they were!?!).

But the situation here is not unique – English  media, like everywhere else, is feeding public with what they want to hear.  Yes, immigrant bashing is a “compulsion”  everywhere, but putting the blame of all of your present problems(and even Greece’s!!) on these Asians is so convenient that nobody wants to deny that pleasure – so what if these ASIANS being talked about were born, brought up and educated here!! No wonder likes of Nasir Hussain, spend their whole life making comments( donkey fielders!!) so that they get accepted in a world they so proudly call theirs.

First let me clarify one thing here – I am not going to cry being racially abused or being treated unfairly by the British media. Reasons -  firstly, I deny to be a part of the group against whom this racial slur is directed, and I have some arrogant reasons for that denial.  Yes, I am going to, out rightly, declare it as a racial abuse but just as a third party spectator. Secondly, after living in UK for 2 years, one does start feeling sorry for the misplaced superiority complex this society carries and hence one starts to laugh upon such racially over toned voices.

In fact I want to take this discussion to a very different level. The very first thing which came to my mind when I read the news today was the AMAR UJJALA’s headline on Godhra Kand in 2001. The paper read – “XX hindu jinda jalaye”. As a 21 year youth(yeah, I was young back then!!) I was shocked at the irresponsibility of one of the leading newspapers of the country(Even though AMAR UJJALA was trying to establish itself in Punjab, it was already big in UP and MP as well I guess). As the years went by I realised that the headline was not irresponsible but a deliberate attempt to align the paper with the majority religion in the states of UP and MP. Newspapers are meant to ease the bowl movement of the reader and hence do not, necessarily, need to be  responsible. I am sure many hindus would have had wonderful visits to the toilets that day.

There have been many instances where you will find Indian media trying to influence the public mood, public perception and even fan the “mob fury” but I have never seen all the media houses trying to curse, bad mouth or abuse the same party or group.  Yes, there are more media houses aligned towards the powerful congress but there are some radical voices which can be heard. But feeding the whole society with the same venomous opinion, time and again is, simply put, unhealthy.  Especially when  the society already carries the (mis)conception of being the rulers of the world!!

Friday, December 30, 2011

Failure of Gandhigiri - Anna calls for political violence


Anna Hazare finally calls for the ouster of the Congress!! 
If satyagrah was a potent enough tool - why did Anna call for this political violence.
If Civil disobedience worked - Quit India would never have been called..

As a CBSE student who was brought up on congress created biased books on "Modern Indian History" - I was always a worshipper of Gandhiji and his principles. Although I must confess that all I knew about these principles was "offer the other cheek" and "the three monkeys".  And I do not know if I still understand any of these.

But the interest in Gandhiji, his principles, how they differed with Bhagat Singh was always there. I remembered to have borrowed a Romain Rolland book on Mahatama, from a friend about 10-12 years ago. I must say that book changed my perspective on the "Father of the nation". Romain describes Mahatama as a social leader who was pushed into politics because of the lack of leadership there after the death of B.G Tilak. He claims that before 1920 all Gandhi was doing was fighting for social causes - equal status for all, Harijan Movements, Women rights - under the British Raj. No wonder congress never pushed for pooran swaraj for many years after the death of Tilak and Quit India Movement had to wait till 1942 to see the light of the day.

Gandhi has always been criticised for being good friends with the Raj - the truth is - he was. He had not asked them to leave the country. Just wanted to be treated with RESPECT. 
Now thats where my first objections to the idea of satyagrah are - you irritate the hell out of the opponent but you never earn their respect. Gandhi could have been a good friends with the RAJ but I doubt he ever earned their respect as an opponent. I agree that - expecting  the  "rulers" to be ashamed of their barbaric legacy is far fetched but if we as a nation would have chased them out of the country, if we had fought back and thrown them out - - they might not have had any superiority complex. 

So is it the time to correct  few wrongs of the past and hand over an embarrassing defeat to the congress. That actually might pave a way for overhauling of the organisation which has some fantastic leaders outside the "royal family". I guess the present call for the kicking the congress out of the power is rightly timed as  the prelude was also necessary. But I also wanna argue that handling the power to BJP just because the Congress does not deserve it - is just foolish to say the least. BJP is just not a mature enough  an organisation to handle any situation - leave alone the power to run the country. 

Any alternatives - ?. 
Just like Gandhi - Anna is not a political leader and do we, as a growing young nation - surrounded by shrewd neighbours and opportunistic friends*,  want to repeat the mistake of pushing another social activist, with similar beliefs, into politics. As I had said in my earlier post - a nation of 1.2b people needs political alternatives. They may come in the form of yoga gurus, film stars, sports persons, religious leaders, IT professionals, NRIs or social activists but they are all required. 

Here is to a better 2012. I am not going to vote in punjab this time  - as I do not want SAD to win and i do not want to vote for congress. Unless, of course, Kiran Bedi decides to fight elections from Amritsar.