Friday, December 30, 2011

Failure of Gandhigiri - Anna calls for political violence


Anna Hazare finally calls for the ouster of the Congress!! 
If satyagrah was a potent enough tool - why did Anna call for this political violence.
If Civil disobedience worked - Quit India would never have been called..

As a CBSE student who was brought up on congress created biased books on "Modern Indian History" - I was always a worshipper of Gandhiji and his principles. Although I must confess that all I knew about these principles was "offer the other cheek" and "the three monkeys".  And I do not know if I still understand any of these.

But the interest in Gandhiji, his principles, how they differed with Bhagat Singh was always there. I remembered to have borrowed a Romain Rolland book on Mahatama, from a friend about 10-12 years ago. I must say that book changed my perspective on the "Father of the nation". Romain describes Mahatama as a social leader who was pushed into politics because of the lack of leadership there after the death of B.G Tilak. He claims that before 1920 all Gandhi was doing was fighting for social causes - equal status for all, Harijan Movements, Women rights - under the British Raj. No wonder congress never pushed for pooran swaraj for many years after the death of Tilak and Quit India Movement had to wait till 1942 to see the light of the day.

Gandhi has always been criticised for being good friends with the Raj - the truth is - he was. He had not asked them to leave the country. Just wanted to be treated with RESPECT. 
Now thats where my first objections to the idea of satyagrah are - you irritate the hell out of the opponent but you never earn their respect. Gandhi could have been a good friends with the RAJ but I doubt he ever earned their respect as an opponent. I agree that - expecting  the  "rulers" to be ashamed of their barbaric legacy is far fetched but if we as a nation would have chased them out of the country, if we had fought back and thrown them out - - they might not have had any superiority complex. 

So is it the time to correct  few wrongs of the past and hand over an embarrassing defeat to the congress. That actually might pave a way for overhauling of the organisation which has some fantastic leaders outside the "royal family". I guess the present call for the kicking the congress out of the power is rightly timed as  the prelude was also necessary. But I also wanna argue that handling the power to BJP just because the Congress does not deserve it - is just foolish to say the least. BJP is just not a mature enough  an organisation to handle any situation - leave alone the power to run the country. 

Any alternatives - ?. 
Just like Gandhi - Anna is not a political leader and do we, as a growing young nation - surrounded by shrewd neighbours and opportunistic friends*,  want to repeat the mistake of pushing another social activist, with similar beliefs, into politics. As I had said in my earlier post - a nation of 1.2b people needs political alternatives. They may come in the form of yoga gurus, film stars, sports persons, religious leaders, IT professionals, NRIs or social activists but they are all required. 

Here is to a better 2012. I am not going to vote in punjab this time  - as I do not want SAD to win and i do not want to vote for congress. Unless, of course, Kiran Bedi decides to fight elections from Amritsar.

Saturday, September 10, 2011

opportunism - a bigger crime than inability.

Yesterday, while reading a little, insignificant article on Amar Singh 's, almost, finished political career my mind was drawn to a shocking fact - three MPs have been detained in the infamous cash-for-cote scam. Two BJP MPs and 1 Amar Singh. None of the members of the main beneficiary party was even held for questioning.

The other day I was listening to Sushma Swaraj's the speech, in response to the Anna Hazare crisis, in Lok Sabha and the lady counted MPs from each non-congress party being roped in one scam or the other by the CBI. And she minced no words in saying that as per CBI every body in congress was clean(Dhood ke dhule) and every other party was full of criminals and frauds(terrorists, murderers, rapists, goons..etc etc etc also!!)

Last few weeks have been turbulent for the congress government at the centre. Anna Hazare had not got off their back yet and Baba RamDev got on. Just as they threw him( and his thousands of innocent supporters) off, Mr Hazare took his turn again. They were still cleaning up the mess they had themselves created that Madam Patil(without asking Madam SG) announced the hanging of assassins of a former prime minister. Just as things seemed to be cooling down - a blast happened. Right in the heart of the Indian capital.
The latest terrorist attack was an embarrassing reminder of our state's inability to protect its ordinary citizen. Terrorists have always been successful at striking at will but this time around they attacked the same place twice, within a short span of time and still our security(even investigating !!) agencies have no clue - what-so-ever.

No thats not as scary..

Let crib a little more here....


If listening to DIGvijay Singh was getting intolerable, Manish Tiwari and Manu Singhavi became frustrating.  The other day Renuka Chaudhary was making some absolutely ridiculous statements. If I had not watched the recording of the interview I would have discarded it off as some media exaggeration as any sensible politician cannot say what I heard her saying!! She essentially meant one thing - when congress said that Anna Hazare movement was a security issue no body believed us so NOW STOP BLAMING US for issues like a bomb blast in the city. And when some panelist questioned that if she thinks that people of India do not have right to sound their opinion as the GOI is incapable of providing them any kind of security - SHE GOT ANGRY!! Now thats the first part of my 'scary' problem. AN ARROGANT, IRRESPONSIBLE, WIDE MOUTHED, DICTATORIAL  government. They can torture colleagues, beat innocent people, jail, fool, lie, bend backwards, bend forwards - do anything to stay in power.

The second part has been, kind of, talked about above. Amar Singh was one time a congress ally, congress has USED the support of these regional political parties at will. Lets start with JK - both NC and PDP have been congress allies at one time or the other. The same can be said about Maya and Mulayam in UP, Pawar in Maharashtra, Jaya and Karuna in TN, Shibhu in Jarkhand so and so forth. All these political parties are in total grasp of the central govt thanks to the effective way in which it uses CBI and other central agencies to its advantage. These allies can not even think of raising any voice of concern against the ruling congress party. So thats the second part of the problem - very weak allies.

One of the most shocking things that seem to have come out of present restlessness is how media has conveniently aligned itself with the government. I had raised concerns about how media was getting powerful and was flexing its muscles at everything.  ( http://warmnsunny.blogspot.com/2009/07/historic-judgement-another-one-scumbs.html )  and if the 2008 bombay attacks were any indication - the media fraternity was not mature enough to handle such power.  But the congress party seems to have learned a few lessons and seems to have taught a few as well. In the present scenario not even a single media channel reported fearlessly against the government. Even now they were highlighting the fact that the home minister has 'wasted no time in asking NIA to investigate the bomb blast in delhi'.  SAD!!


Now the most scary part, and fortunately this is the last. A DIRECTIONLESS, HAPLESS opposition. With issues ranging from AirIndia debacle to price rise to multi-crore scams to terrorists attacks - BJP has had exactly 2 reactions - interrupt the proceedings of the parliament when inside it and ask for resignation of the PM when outside. Now Cyrus Broacha might want to call it a focussed effort!! But with the kind of anti-gvernment sentiment we have in India right now - BJP was/is incapable of creating any kind of mass movement out of it. Their leaders have been issuing the demands of the PM resignation so frequently that no body takes them seriously any more. Even now when congress has nothing to say to questions asked by normal men and women - BJP leaders mainly remain unanswered. Left has never had any significant presence outside WB and Kerala. And and I can not think of any other party/leader whom I can even think of being in 'opposition'. 

.. for another three years that is!!

Some would like to debate that this is most scary part of the problem that we WILL have to live 'under the congress' RULE for another 3years but in defence to my judgment I want to ask do we have an option even if we think of not voting for the congress - I am not going to vote for Navjot Singh Sidhu, or SAD.  

In my view its the BJP, the other opposition parties, opportunistic UPA allies who are the real murderers of the democracy. INC has just been opportunistic and in a country where a citizen justifies his insensitivity(towards the state or society) by saying that he has to earn the evening meal, where success of man is determined by the amount of money he has earned - opportunism cannot be a bigger crime than inability.


















Wednesday, August 17, 2011

phew!! jan lokpal..

The opinions are strong and emotions are high..
The society(FB or otherwise) has been mainly divided into two groups - people who have been following the ANNA movement, know whats at stake and hence have strong opinion for or against ANNA. Secondly the people who caught the news when it reached prime time, heard it on all the news channels in one hour and 'share'd an opinion with the journalist.

These people whom I have classified as the 'second' group  are the real soul of India, who work from dawn till evening, people who actually have to fight with everyday issues which our corrupt and inefficient system throws at us. These are the people, who in spite of all the 'business losses', do make it a point to cast their vote, these are the people who think and hope that their franchise will actually make a difference. So these are the people take out whatever time hey can for the nation, society. And for all these reasons these are the people who have the actual right to form an opinion about issues such as this. Unlike the less ignorant ones who, probably from their birth time, knew that nothing is going to change so they do not vote, or since the elections always take place when they have an important meeting or trip.

But unfortunately the people, whom I classify as the real soul of India, are always exploited the most by the powers that may be - politicians or media, babas or celebrities. So basics of this Anna movement is the same - get this group behind you. To their credit - the Anna team has been very very transparent in their approach . They have published their demands in all the possible forms and on all possible platforms. They have tried to explain it to the people what their demands mean and what 'they think' is going to change if their demands are met.  Anna ji has a very clean character as even congress' most efficient sniffers could not find any thing against him or his close aides. Such person does deserve all the support he needs to put forward his idea and I think he must be answered honestly by the people which we have elected.

But the question is how many of the people who are at the streets actually understand that tabling a draft of a bill is no victory by any means, how many of the people think - how adding another bureaucratic position in our already complex bureaucratic system is going to help the common man? Do all of these people even know or have thought about how these lokpals are going to be appointed or transferred or 'enquired' or suspended. Are all these people ready for an IAS officer sitting on top of all our political system - given that we have more than 50% reservation in government appointment/promotion system.

First things first - let me present an hypothetical situation. Tomorrow, lets assume that, the govt agrees to the demands of the team Anna and tables their draft of the lokpal bill in the parliament. Now congress 'high command' issues a public statement that all its MPs have a democratic right to decide if they want to vote for or against the bill - do we think even a single congress MP is going to vote in favor of the bill. BJP, as double standard as they  are, are they going to vote in favour?? they will always want this issue to hang around, passing it makes life so easier for congress, so why will BJP vote in its favor?  So the chances of the bill becoming a law are very very bleak. Do these people, on the streets, even know that they might have come out again when the 'lower house' rejects the bill(and that could be 'release time' for many!! Sorry for this bad joke.. ).

Now lets assume that the team Anna, given that they have been spot on with their timing and campaigning, are able to pull out three  or four 'revolutions' and get to pass all these hurdles. We have a new Lokpal anointed( by Congress or by reservation!!). He enjoys absolute power to question anybody, including the PM, military brass??, NSA, Foreign Sec so and so forth... What happens if such a person is corrupt or biased or politically/socially inclined. Who measures the performance for him - in other words who has the power to 'transfer' him. A PM(selected by SG), a president (selected by SG), parliament('majority led' by SG, 'opposition led' by 'SS', session led by Miera LOL Kumar), or a supreme court bench.
The makers of our constitution had invested absolute powers in the hands of elected representatives of the people. Hence by the spirit of our constitution - the 'aam aadmi' has the indirect absolute power. We, over the period of time, have been casting our votes for money, a bottle of liquor, religion, cast. Now, all of sudden, some body tells us that a revolution is just a click away and we, frustrated over our own failures,   are, quiet understandably,  going to give in and believe. It s easy, free and hence makes sense.

Now another question which, I am sure, will further divide all those on the street - Will we support 50% reservation for the post of Lokpal, 33% women reservation as well?? I know this question can be answered later but do we think the lokpal, assuming that he got selected coz he belonged to a certain caste or certain tribe, will not be biased. Do we think a such a person, who does not get selected because of his abilities but for other reasons,  will not be politically or economically (in other words - bribed, corrupt) biased.  We all have heard horror stories of IAS/IPS officers preparing the choona/pan masala for our MPs and MLAs - so do we know the answer if the LOKPAL will be the product of this bureaucratic-political system or not.

On a second(or sober) thought - if I read what all I am saying can simply be described as a knee jerk reaction of a very pessimist man. But then to my defence - I will never describe myself as a pessimist of any degree and secondly I am more worried about the people who think the 'revolution' is just a bill, mouse-click or march away..
But as I had written in my last post one more option is not going to hurt 1.2 billion(ok 50% of 1.2 billion) voters.. and Anna's team is more than a good political option this revolution is going to give us.


Sunday, June 5, 2011

Feet in the mouth...both!!

So much to say, condem, appreciate, laugh at, cry for... this one to just gather my thoughts and then decide which side I am on..
When I first heard about the 'fast' plans from the Baba - I was amused. All of his demands seemed unrealistic to me. Yes. All!! I don't think any group of politicians and bureaucrats can, over nightly,  come up with a plan to get all the black money stowed in tax havens, neither it is practical for the government to promise a capital punishment for those proven corrupt( All government can do is draft a bill and table it in the parliament and, that, I am afraid, is going to be the fate of 'Anna's bill')

Then came the congress' over reaction to the situation. Although the ruling party's worries are not entirely uncalled for - they have reasons to believe that a baba can risk the stability of a government (something on that later..) but the way the party bent backwards to appease baba was comical. My reaction to situation was that congress has let media take it to the prime time and now BJP is (and media as well, of course)  going to feast on it. Baba could not have asked for a better 'promotion' for his drama.
In fact let me suggest SRK to pay some money to a couple of Congress ministers and ask them to come and receive him at the delhi airport just before the release of his next 'movie'. Those inverted commas around the word 'movie' are intentional.

Talks fail - as expected. To be fair to baba, any body with any political aspirations could NOT have missed that opportunity to get so much media coverage.

But the last thing I expected from Congress party was to show any aggression. To me, as far as I can remember, congress has been a spineless organisation, thrusting home ministers like ShivrajP and PMs like PVNR and MMS (even DeveGowda for that matter) on the country. Wish KapilS was asked to handle babri masjid crisis!! Although I firmly believe that today is the darkest day in the history of Indian democracy (- I was too young in 1984 and did not understand these things in 1992) but I think that the ruling party did save the nation many many fasts by showing some guts and they could not have delayed it a day further.

I have no doubt in my mind congress SHOULD NOT get away by taking this miscalculated risk. And for the first time I am endorsing the opposition stand that congress does not have any democratic right to be in power any more. I think its the time for the allies to show some guts.**

Congress is of course finding it very difficult to explain its action and hence its ministers have been giving most ridiculous statements(missing Jayanti again!!). The most animated of these congress men has been Digvijay Singh - the most corrupt one, of course. All the online community has taken up so much dig at the statements made by these congress men that KapilS must have been sleeping with both his feet in his mouth. I DO NOT expect the same from DIGvijay Singh as we all know its not the first time for him.

**Hold on. Let me fetch the list of UPA allies, expected to show guts against the congress - too unfair and too high an expectation from Shibhu Soren, FarooqA, Karunanidhi, SharadP. Only UPA party in a position to take that risk is PDP. So no matter how much the opposition shouts, the congress is going to continue ruling, unabashedly. As I doubt a possibility of a mass public movement to oust the current government as people can not be motivated enough to choose a leaderless opposition.

That is where we need alternatives. Agree that a saffron clad, orthodox baba might not be an ideal alternative but still as a nation of 1.2 billion we need more choices both in terms of personalities and in terms of ideologies.

That is why a strong left is as important an opposition as a reckless BJP. That is where a powerful patriotic baba is as important as a communal RSS brigade. So I think at the end of all this - baba gets my full support as I want him to become a political force that can threaten both the congress and the BJP.

The last thing I want to hear tomorrow is that the BABA is joining BJP and contesting elections in UP, on BJP ticket, as Mayawati did not give him permissions to hoist his protest in noida!!

Saturday, April 2, 2011

The turban story...

Just as Indian cricket team was planning to take on their pakistani counter parts and the two nations were well immersed in the euphoria - a small little storm was brewing in punjab(Indian side).


Not that a couple of police officers being suspended for hurting the religious sentiments of a community is anything to write about, but the shocking thing which took away, at least, a couple of hours of my sleep was a consistent stream of provoking messages on facebook by a certain section of my friends.


First the news. What I saw from the clipped footage available all over the internet - Two police officers a sikh and a hindu, man handling a Sikh youth, sikh officer hands over the youth to the hindu officer - cautioning him not to remove the turban, but Hindu guy does remove the turban of the sikh youth - infact the first thing he does after he lays his hands on the youth.


Now the reaction. If you search videos over the internet for what people are saying about the incident you will see people talking about Khalistan, Azadi, Congress, Manmohan Singh, 84 riots, chandigarh not being a part of Punjab among so many other things. And yes I am deliberately listing down the reactions of ONLY the people who have been invited by different channels to give their expert views on the incident, problems brought forward by it and their solutions


Now let me create the profile of the people who feel that a separate sikh state is the only solution. These people can be broadly classified into ONE category - politicians. Some heading the some student federation, some heading some religious organisation, so on and so forth.. There was a category of people who felt hurt and were spitting venom and, again, these guys could also be classified in exactly ONE category - youths - mostly working/living outside the country ( or their very close family members), have a limited access to news and mostly view programs which are custom created for them.


Now the problem. Having born and brought up in a troubled punjab , I have always felt sorry for the people of Kashmir. I always believed that it is in the best interest of kashmiris to stick with India but the price they are paying for this is just too much. Its high time that they should be let alone to live.


But the problem in punjab is at a different stage, if not entirely different. Here we have a prosperous community which has been made to feel insecure by its own leaders over the past three decades, a community which has been made to believe that an incident like the one happened last week is a state propaganda against the whole community, a community which has been made to feel, behave and act like a minority by its own leaders. So every time something happens - they takes to the streets, kill the innocent people, destroy the state property. How on earth do you justify the powerful sikh class has had bloody spats with hindus living in the state, Sikh Namdaris, Sikh followers of other sects( deras). Its a community which has lots of money, lots of free time, easy access to drugs, poor education, and above all irresponsible leadership.


The troubled history of punjab can be broadly divided in three parts.. before 1984, between 1984 and 1992/3 when Beant Singh took over and after the death of Beant Singh. Now to sum up that punjabi youths took to the militancy before 84 just because their only demand of giving chandigrah to punjab was not met - WOULD NOT BE AN OVER STATEMENT. Any body who thinks differently has either not read the facts himself or has some vested interests in keeping this fire still burning.


I fully agree that whatever happened in 84 was a gross exaggeration of the situation in hand by the military and political power there be. But can we actually blame the military for believing that only they can handle a situation. About the then prime minister - I would let you believe whatever your parents have told you about her. I have a great respect for her from whatever I have read about her.


And then followed the rampage. A separate sikh state was the demand of the hour and easiest way to make people hear you was a bomb blast or a gun fire. Money and arms poured in from all the corners of earth and even a small(holy?) city like Amritsar witnessed blood shed every day. I feel sorry for people who still get agitated that 84 delhi riot victims have not got justice. We have had our relatives killed in punjab in the same time frame and we don't even know whom to go to, for justice. But I am proud of the way my parents, my relatives and in fact all hindus in punjab have got over the situation and don't CRIB about it anymore. I wonder my parents never shared those horror stories of me being thrown from the roof top of our house into the varandah of our sikh neighbours as we heard that some people are planning to burn down all hindu houses in the area. I came to know about the story when I was already married.


Then(1992) something happened, presidential rule in Punjab was to be replaced with a democratically elected govt and AKALIs boycotted the election. Now I think PV N Rao should have been the prime minister of India when those elections were announced and if its true than it has to bravest decision taken by that person in his life. I still don't believe that he was able to force Akalis to keep out of the election, just wonder if there was any Sonia Gandhi behind all that even then?!?!


Yes, I cant think of any other reasons for Akalis to boycott the elections.. they must have been asked to keep out of the way. Congress won the elections, and within a year or two wiped off all the troubling elements from the state. It is then that I started reading punjab kesari - a brave news paper which actually reported the dark side of these 'freedom fighter'. During the time when militants were being wiped out from the state, many of them ran away to the foreign lands. In fact now when I look back and think - only people who got killed during those times were the youths belonging to the poor class of the society. Anybody who could afford to run away actually did. The Akalis became powerful and started exerting absolute power even over the religious bodies.

Now coming back to present situation in Punjab - since most the troubled elements were just being silenced and Akalis have been reduced to just Badals, every small 'opportunity' is exploited to talk about the need for taking to arms, a separate state, hostile central government. All this sounds normal, there is nothing alarming about it - but as I said the most troubling aspect is that even most educated, well travelled, well informed class of the community is still an easy prey to these propaganda and even they are ready to pump in resources. money( not their jobs r careers, mind it!!) to any such call of an armed revolution for a separate state.


Just a food for thought…


How on earth does Punjab even think of survival on its own - when the ONLY surviving industry there is Agriculture and that is tax free, the govt offices are drastically underemployed and those employed are ridiculously over payed, we have no leader in the state who has come to the fore own his own, most of the MPs and MLAs which come from the state are either relatives of Badal or his wife.