Wow! it has been seven years since I wrote anything!
If I did not know myself any better, I would say that the old age has calmed me down. But the truth is that I have, just, not felt motivated enough to write anything. Post Arvind Kejriwal/IAC era everybody has become an expert and polarisation is so absolute that it has become impossible to have a constructive discussion.
The only reason, I am trying to jot down my thoughts today, is that I have been asked, time and again, by a friend to put down my strong views on different topics, we discuss in our chats.
And, removal of special status afforded to J&K seemed as good a topic as any.
I must confess I am still struggling to get my thoughts together on this. My first reaction was that it was very brave step and only Modi could have done it.
But that was exact reaction on demonetisation - A very bold move, something which was long overdue!
But what was wrong with demonetisation, or air-strikes on PoK or GST - they were all undercooked policies, hasty decisions followed by loud and vulgar publicity.
Congress has created some wonderful policies over the years but what Congress could never achieve was - any success in implementing them. Has BJP achieved any success with demonetisation, GST, Smart villages, Swach Bharat or even MNREGA or Adhar Card deployment? Bhagats will tell you their side of the story but my argument is that we have not seen a positive impact of any of these on the ground.
Every policy is still a promise, still a dream.
One major difference I have seen this time around is that BJP leaders are not patting their own back on the current "achievement" but, still, there is no shortage of vulgar jokes on the social media.
And that is my concern in all this.
And that is my concern in all this.
From the political standpoint it makes sense to bifurcate J&K. This will give government of India better control and, perhaps, better access to different parts of the region. But I would have liked to see Jammu distanced from the troubled land. Jammu has mostly been a peaceful city and people there identify themselves as Indians. I have always thought that people of Jammu have been suffering unnecessarily all these years. It would have made more sense to cut Jammu out, long ago. While Congress never had enough guts to bifurcate the state, it seems it suits BJP to keep Jammu and Kashmir together, political demographics and all!
It also makes sense to include J&K into the mainland India. Once kashmiri youth starts working in Delhis, Bangalurus and Hydrabads of the country, they will find out what India has to offer - a truly secular nation which is just polarised by the politicians and their social media cells.( and, of course, criticised by Sonia Deols).
It also makes sense to include J&K into the mainland India. Once kashmiri youth starts working in Delhis, Bangalurus and Hydrabads of the country, they will find out what India has to offer - a truly secular nation which is just polarised by the politicians and their social media cells.( and, of course, criticised by Sonia Deols).
But, I am worried how this is celebrated as a victory by huge middle class of the country, which, actually, does not have any knowledge of the history of the state. I can bet many of those who sent me those "jokes" on social media do not even know why was article 370 added to the constitution. They praise Patel and swear on Nehru-Gandhi family without knowing what the Kashmir issue is, without knowing anything about circumstances and conditions under which India was allowed to send its armed forces into Kashmir in 1947.
As I have advocated many a times in the past, since Kashmiri youth does not want to be a part of India, they should be given their place and peace.
Personally, I know some kashmiri pundits who were threatened and kicked out of their homes and I know that that generation wanted to go back. But if you ask the next generation who has been educated in mainland India, I do not think they care. They consider themselves lucky to have escaped a war zone.
To my suggestions on "giving Kashmir to Kashmiris", I have heard counter arguments like
- This is not good for the security of the country as it gives both China and Pakistan a better access to mainland India.
- This will set a bad precedent and then we will have to give away Assam, Gorkhaland and Punjab.
- This is what Pakistan wants, and India cannot be seen defeated by a country whose only contribution to humanity is the terrorist camps(and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan!!).
As I have advocated many a times in the past, since Kashmiri youth does not want to be a part of India, they should be given their place and peace.
Personally, I know some kashmiri pundits who were threatened and kicked out of their homes and I know that that generation wanted to go back. But if you ask the next generation who has been educated in mainland India, I do not think they care. They consider themselves lucky to have escaped a war zone.
To my suggestions on "giving Kashmir to Kashmiris", I have heard counter arguments like
- This is not good for the security of the country as it gives both China and Pakistan a better access to mainland India.
- This will set a bad precedent and then we will have to give away Assam, Gorkhaland and Punjab.
- This is what Pakistan wants, and India cannot be seen defeated by a country whose only contribution to humanity is the terrorist camps(and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan!!).
And while I do not have a logical answer to all these valid points - my romanticised argument is that where are the interests of the kashmiri youth in all these? This issue has already destroyed 3-4 generations of Kashmiris and the world is no more wise than it was in 1947. Pakistan is still exporting terrorists to every corner of the world and will continue to do that. UK, China, US(even toe-nail sized countries of Europe) will like to continue to sell arms and ammunitions to this part of the world and hence will want this to be a burning issue for another 80 years.
Someone has to think about the people of kashmir.