Friday, December 30, 2011

Failure of Gandhigiri - Anna calls for political violence


Anna Hazare finally calls for the ouster of the Congress!! 
If satyagrah was a potent enough tool - why did Anna call for this political violence.
If Civil disobedience worked - Quit India would never have been called..

As a CBSE student who was brought up on congress created biased books on "Modern Indian History" - I was always a worshipper of Gandhiji and his principles. Although I must confess that all I knew about these principles was "offer the other cheek" and "the three monkeys".  And I do not know if I still understand any of these.

But the interest in Gandhiji, his principles, how they differed with Bhagat Singh was always there. I remembered to have borrowed a Romain Rolland book on Mahatama, from a friend about 10-12 years ago. I must say that book changed my perspective on the "Father of the nation". Romain describes Mahatama as a social leader who was pushed into politics because of the lack of leadership there after the death of B.G Tilak. He claims that before 1920 all Gandhi was doing was fighting for social causes - equal status for all, Harijan Movements, Women rights - under the British Raj. No wonder congress never pushed for pooran swaraj for many years after the death of Tilak and Quit India Movement had to wait till 1942 to see the light of the day.

Gandhi has always been criticised for being good friends with the Raj - the truth is - he was. He had not asked them to leave the country. Just wanted to be treated with RESPECT. 
Now thats where my first objections to the idea of satyagrah are - you irritate the hell out of the opponent but you never earn their respect. Gandhi could have been a good friends with the RAJ but I doubt he ever earned their respect as an opponent. I agree that - expecting  the  "rulers" to be ashamed of their barbaric legacy is far fetched but if we as a nation would have chased them out of the country, if we had fought back and thrown them out - - they might not have had any superiority complex. 

So is it the time to correct  few wrongs of the past and hand over an embarrassing defeat to the congress. That actually might pave a way for overhauling of the organisation which has some fantastic leaders outside the "royal family". I guess the present call for the kicking the congress out of the power is rightly timed as  the prelude was also necessary. But I also wanna argue that handling the power to BJP just because the Congress does not deserve it - is just foolish to say the least. BJP is just not a mature enough  an organisation to handle any situation - leave alone the power to run the country. 

Any alternatives - ?. 
Just like Gandhi - Anna is not a political leader and do we, as a growing young nation - surrounded by shrewd neighbours and opportunistic friends*,  want to repeat the mistake of pushing another social activist, with similar beliefs, into politics. As I had said in my earlier post - a nation of 1.2b people needs political alternatives. They may come in the form of yoga gurus, film stars, sports persons, religious leaders, IT professionals, NRIs or social activists but they are all required. 

Here is to a better 2012. I am not going to vote in punjab this time  - as I do not want SAD to win and i do not want to vote for congress. Unless, of course, Kiran Bedi decides to fight elections from Amritsar.